We have detected you are using Internet Explorer. To provide the best and most secure experience, please use a modern browser as we do not support Internet Explorer.

OA of the hip: The HIT Trial

Osteoarthritis is by far and away the most common form of arthritis in Australia.
The 2017–18 National Health Survey (NHS) estimated that 2.2 million Australians have this condition, or one in eleven people in the population. Osteoarthritis has a huge impact, both on the individual and also the health system. And it can be a frustrating condition to manage, with limited evidence-based options for care.

A recently published research paper describes impressive results for a non-surgical intervention. Our colleagues from NB Medical in the UK describe this in their latest blog, published with permission here.

Osteoarthritis of the hip: common, painful, hugely limiting to function and quality of life and now post pandemic we and our patients face huge delays and barriers to surgical referral. We advise patients on weight loss, we refer if we can for physio and structured exercise programmed but the patient with pain and limitations on their quality of life and function keep coming back to us for help. What next?

To be fair, the treatment cupboard for OA has always looked pretty bare but it is barer still now that paracetamol and weak opioids have been removed as recommendations in the new draft NICE guidelines for OA NICE OA draft guideline, 2022. So, apart from weight loss and exercise, what else can we offer?

A recent trial called the HIT trial has published 2022;377;e068446. It deserves a prize for its short and punchy acronym alone (the Hip Injection Trial), but the results are similarly impressive. Patients with mild to moderate OA hip, but with significant pain and functional limitation, were randomised to best current treatment (BCT) comprising education and information or BCT plus ultrasound guided injection of local anaesthetic (lidocaine) plus or minus steroid (triamcinolone).  The improvements in the injection groups were rapid and sustained. For the combined injection patients had a 50% reduction in pain scores at 2 weeks, with a mean improvement of 25% over 6 months. The NNT at 2 months were just 2 for improved sleep, 3 for feeling better and 3 for no limits to functional activity. Those are impressive results. At 6 months pain relief was not sustained but functional improvements persisted.

Interestingly, the anti-inflammatory effect of the steroid was most beneficial when the scan revealed active synovitis or effusion.  It suggests the anti-inflammatory benefits will be greater earlier in the disease process when there is still some joint lining to become actively inflamed. Once we get to ‘bone on bone’ it is an intervention which is less likely to help.  In an accompanying editorial BMJ2022;377:o1028 the authors discuss how this confirms that we should discard the old view of OA as being due to ‘wear and tear’, and conceptualise the pathology instead as a model of ‘tear, flare and repair’. The term ‘wear and tear’ arthritis should be abandoned;  it is negatively framed, reinforces expectations of inexorable decline and discourages exercise and use which we know is beneficial.

So, we have a non-surgical intervention for OA that gives rapid and effective short-term relief whilst patients are waiting for surgery. Let us hope our commissioners make it available to us and our patients just as rapidly!

This blog was originally published on nbmedical.com


If you're interested in keeping up to date on the latest developments in primary care, check out the GP Education Bundle. A triennium worth of CPD, this bundle gives you access to the Medcast & NB Medical course Hot Topics, as well as our other premium GP courses including Emergencies in General Practice (accredited for 40 RACGP Accredited CPD Points), the popular 'Not to be missed' series and much more. Click here to learn more.
{{commentCount}} comment(s). You must be logged in and AHPRA verified to view and comment. LOG IN
Dr Simon Curtis

Dr Simon Curtis

Simon is the Medical Director NB Medical Education, an NHS GP in Oxford and Hon Senior Clinical Lecturer in General Practice, Oxford University.

The latest healthcare news from medcast

Examination of patients presenting following sexual violence within an intimate partner violence relationship
Examination of patients presenting following sexual violence within an intimate partner violence relationship

General practitioners (GPs) are often the first contact for patients who are victims of intimate partner violence (IPV) including sexual assault.

Erectile Dysfunction: Clinical Summary Guide
Erectile Dysfunction: Clinical Summary Guide

Did you know that an Australian study found that the majority (61%) of Australian men aged over 45 have some form of erectile dysfunction?

Clinical Opal #16 - Vaccine preventable disease
Clinical Opal #16 - Vaccine preventable disease

Jose is a 9 year unvaccinated child with a 5 day history of a low grade fever, cough and sore throat...

Netflix and chill
Netflix and chill

If a good friend suggested to you that, instead of going to the movies together, you just go home to “Netflix and chill” how would you respond?

Clinical Opal #15 - “It’s as easy as ABCD2... or not.”
Clinical Opal #15 - “It’s as easy as ABCD2... or not.”

Duc, a 57 year old accountant, presents to you one afternoon with a recent episode of slurred speech...

Strategies for surviving the news
Strategies for surviving the news

“Mass shootings are part of the American landscape….”

OA of the hip: The HIT Trial
OA of the hip: The HIT Trial

Osteoarthritis is by far and away the most common form of arthritis in Australia.

Clinical Opal #14 - CVD risk and statins in patients with CKD
Clinical Opal #14 - CVD risk and statins in patients with CKD

Graeme, a 64-year-old retired builder, presented to you for repeat prescriptions two weeks previously as a new patient to the practice...

Clinical Opal #13 - 41 year old with hip pain
Clinical Opal #13 - 41 year old with hip pain

Zoe is a 41-year-old graphic designer who presents to you with right hip pain...

Clinical Opal #12 - Deterioration post abdominoplasty
Clinical Opal #12 - Deterioration post abdominoplasty

Gail is a 63 year old post abdominoplasty who is complaining of tingling lips, abdominal cramping and watery eyes...

What makes a mental health app work?
What makes a mental health app work?

Clinicians I talk to often say that they recommend mental health apps all the time, but they find that even the most enthusiastic users seem to disengage pretty quickly.

GP Educational Intervention Improves Patient Care and My Health Record Usage with Potential to Save Government Millions
GP Educational Intervention Improves Patient Care and My Health Record Usage with Potential to Save Government Millions

A two-year study titled CHIME-GP was carried out by Medcast and the University of Wollongong. It has shown that educating GPs about potentially inappropriate or unnecessary medicines, imaging and pathology test ordering in the context of using the My...

More than a race: Medcast takes on the Shitbox Rally – Autumn 2022
More than a race: Medcast takes on the Shitbox Rally – Autumn 2022

From Wollongong, NSW to Mackay, QLD in 7 days. Medcast’s own team, Tyre Kickers, are taking on Shitbox Rally – Autumn 2022.

Clinical Opal #11 - SGLT2i-related DKA
Clinical Opal #11 - SGLT2i-related DKA

Terese is a 64-year-old retired teacher who has a 12 year history of type 2 diabetes. She also has hypertension...

Have you lost your mojo?
Have you lost your mojo?

I’m pretty sure I’ve lost mine. I lost it in the early part of 2021 and haven’t laid eyes on it since.

Promoting reproductive choice in primary care
Promoting reproductive choice in primary care

The Australian Contraception and Abortion Primary Care Practitioner Support Network (AusCAPPS) - a network for professionals working with women to optimise reproductive health

How Doctors Think
How Doctors Think

In this short video from the 2022 'Not to be missed' webinar series, Dr Simon Morgan provides some insights into how Doctors think.

Are we all ok?
Are we all ok?

Often OK is the very best I can do (especially lately), and I try to be grateful for that, but wouldn’t it be nice to be more than OK, to be flourishing, for a little more of the time! I hope I don’t have to wait for the world to be a better place be...

Clinical Opal #10 - Pre-conception care
Clinical Opal #10 - Pre-conception care

Kelly, aged 28, presents for an appointment as she is planning a pregnancy with her husband. She has no significant medical history, is nulliparous, is a non-smoker, has normal body weight, maintains a healthy diet and exercise routine, and has a con...

How connecting to my Aboriginality helps me stay strong
How connecting to my Aboriginality helps me stay strong

Being connected to your Aboriginal heritage can bring fulfilment and a sense of identity and culture but what about wellbeing?

Join Medcast. It's free and you'll get instant access to essential healthcare news, research and more.

Already a member? Log In