Developing Clinical Reasoning to Tackle the KFP

As a GP, we are undertaking clinical reasoning with nearly every patient that we see. It is most often automatic. However, in preparation for the KFP exam, it can be helpful to deconstruct the clinical reasoning process. The ultimate goal, however, is to make us better clinicians, not just to pass the exam!
As a GP, we are undertaking clinical reasoning with nearly every patient. It is most often automatic. However, in preparation for the KFP exam, it can be helpful to deconstruct the clinical reasoning process. The ultimate goal, however, is to make us better clinicians, not just to pass the exam!

A definition of clinical reasoning includes an ability to integrate and apply knowledge, to weigh evidence, critically think about arguments and to reflect upon the process used to arrive at a diagnosis. We learn this at the bedside of our consultants and supervisors. It implies that we have a good knowledge of medicine, and the conditions that we encounter. We should have an “illness script” for each condition, so that we can compare it to the bank of other conditions in our illness script “filing cabinet” (pattern recognition).

Dual Process Theory

It is important to know about Dual Process Theory when we are talking about Clinical Reasoning. As medical students, we are taught Type 2 thinking – this is a slow, methodical, logical process driven type of thinking, where we are taught to take a history from the patient, formulate differential diagnoses, and rule those differentials in or out by further history, physical examination and investigations. Type 1 thinking is intuitive, fast, automatic and experiential. This is developed as you become more experienced.

A good clinical thinker routinely approaches a clinical presentation by using a combination of Type 1 and Type 2 thinking.  The nonanalytic approach is more common, accounting for 80% of clinical reasoning and is based on pattern (or illness script) recognition(2).

Preparing for the KFP

When preparing for the KFP, be aware of which type of thinking you are using. It is important to see as many patients as possible in the lead up to the exam, and use them to practice your clinical reasoning. Practice your Type 2 Reasoning, and use Murtagh’s PROMPT as a framework to do this.

Any history questions, physical examination and investigations should be targeted at ruling in and ruling out your differentials and red flags. The 'Masquerades' and 'Often Missed' should be thought of, and investigated if appropriate.

There are several good resources to help improve your clinical reasoning.

  1. Being aware of Diagnostic error is important. This article on Life in the Fastlane is helpful. 
  2. IM Reasoning Podcast is helpful, particularly the “Stump the Chumps” Episodes. If you do a lot of driving or walking, these podcasts are invaluable. Can be downloaded from App store, or found at IM Reasoning
  3. An AFP article on learning Clinical Reasoning
  4. The Society to Improve Diagnosis in Medicine has a website, which has a Clinical Reasoning Toolkit, with several resources. If you are interested in reading more about this area, I suggest that you look at this.

Medcast Exam Preparation Courses

Did you know that Medcast now offers an intensive 15-week exam preparation course? Our Boot Camp is an interactive small group course where you will be mentored by highly experienced medical educators, get feedback on your performance, review exam questions and ideal answers, and discuss strategies and exam technique. Click here to find out more.

{{commentCount}} comment(s). You must be logged in and AHPRA verified to view and comment. Login here.

Dr Allison Miller

Allison is a GP with over 20 years experience. She is a Medical Educator (ME) for a GP Training Provider and has been an OSCE examiner with the RACGP since 2010. Allison is one of the expert MEs that co-facilitate the Medcast exam preparation courses.

The latest healthcare news from medcast

Aging Well – a personal perspective
Aging Well – a personal perspective

At 65 and a half (yes, it’s come to that. I’m actually counting the months again!) I find myself reluctantly looking down the barrel of a shotgun labelled “old age”.  It’s OK, don’t panic – I’m not unwell. It’s just that my body hurts and people k...

The CHIME GP study
The CHIME GP study

looking at rational prescribing and test ordering in general practice to improve

Muuuum, I’m bored!!!!
Muuuum, I’m bored!!!!

Has anyone heard that or a variation of it recently? I’ll bet you have! Many years ago, before I had kids of my own, I used to hear my brother-in-law saying to his bored and whining kids “Come on then, I’ll give you a job. I’ve got plenty for y...

What’s your COVID number? A simple way to keep everyone safe and comfortable
What’s your COVID number? A simple way to keep everyone safe and comfortable

A friend mentioned a really great way for managing this which I have been using and sharing with others. As people are going to have different comfort levels when it comes to spending time together, she told me about sharing her COVID social comfo...

Being Well in Difficult Times - Talah
Being Well in Difficult Times - Talah

It’s always helpful to hear how other people cope.  Over the next few weeks we are dedicating the Being Well blog to a series called Being Well in Difficult Times.  In this blog post we speak to Talah - a a Gumbaynggirr/Yaegl young person who shar...

We’re listening at last to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voices in Mental Health
We’re listening at last to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voices in Mental Health

Whilst significant progress has been made in incorporating these voices generally, there is a call for diversity in these Lived Experience voices, namely Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Lived Experience.

Being Well in Difficult Times- Zoe
Being Well in Difficult Times- Zoe

Zoe is a registered nurse working in theatres. She has elderly parents and a young son. How is she staying so positive in the face of CoVID-19?

Eating Disorders in Adults: Assessment & Treatment Options
Eating Disorders in Adults: Assessment & Treatment Options

Eating disorders, broadly defined by disturbances in eating behaviour and distress centred on food, eating, and body image, affect nearly one million Australians. This blog covers the assessment and treatment options for various conditions.

Being Well in Difficult Times - Gordon
Being Well in Difficult Times - Gordon

Gordon* is a thirty something rural proceduralist GP. Gordon contributed to the national guidelines for the management of COVID-19. Would being in his shoes change your thinking about the pandemic?

Being Well in Difficult Times - Sally
Being Well in Difficult Times - Sally

Sally* is the director of new urban private practice. She is a generalist psychologist & qualified teacher in her mid-forties with two ‘tween girls, and vulnerable (but fit) parents. Her clients include young children, teenagers, university studen...

Being Well in Difficult Times - Margot
Being Well in Difficult Times - Margot

It’s always helpful to hear how other people cope with life's challenges. Over the next few weeks we are dedicating the Being Well blog to a series called Being Well in Difficult Times. We've asked a range of health professionals 3 big questions t...

Being Well in Difficult Times- Elizabeth
Being Well in Difficult Times- Elizabeth

How would you feel if you were pregnant right now? It would probably add a whole other dimension to your concern. What if, to add to the puzzle, your work made you responsible for the mental health of others? Elizabeth* is a thirty-something s...

Being Well in Difficult Times - Dr Vered Gordon
Being Well in Difficult Times - Dr Vered Gordon

Dr Vered Gordon is a GP in Sydney’s Northern Beaches with a special interest in perinatal mental health. For more than a decade Vered developed Black Dog Institute’s highly regarded Professional Education workshops.

Being Well in Difficult Times- Michael Kidd
Being Well in Difficult Times- Michael Kidd

It’s always helpful to hear how other people cope with life's challenges. Over the next few weeks we are dedicating the Being Well blog to a series called Being Well in Difficult Times. Michael's CoVID-19 job responsibilities are huge and his...

Communication in the time of COVID-19
Communication in the time of COVID-19

The COVID-19 pandemic has led to a massive, and almost overnight, transformation in Australian general practice, most notably with the rapid rise in telehealth. What does effective communication via telehealth look like?

KISS - COVID-19 Primary Care Assessment & Management
KISS - COVID-19 Primary Care Assessment & Management

This Keep It Simple Summary (KISS) covers the treatment and management of COVID-19 in the Primary Care environment. Stages of the disease will be explained, followed by a succinct summary risk factors, symptoms, complications, treatment, respirato...

Reframing Isolation
Reframing Isolation

I keep wondering about what we can learn from all these people who live in isolation or confinement. What strategies were put in place and what might the long-term impact of their isolation have been?

Non-drug Approaches to Chronic Pain Management
Non-drug Approaches to Chronic Pain Management

Living with chronic pain is a complex health issue that affects over 3.2 million Australians, with close to 68% of those affected being of working age. As we know, chronic pain can have significant implications on daily functions and quality of l...

Telehealth: How does it work In Practice
Telehealth: How does it work In Practice

We are all starting to do telehealth in the current climate to protect us, our staff and our patients. Many of us feel slightly out of our depth. Here are some quick tips to help you in your practice.

COVID-19 and Us
COVID-19 and Us

Have you thought about what these measures are going to mean for you personally? Even if we avoid the need for self-isolation, we will all need to practice social distancing for possibly 6-12 months until we can all be vaccinated, or until we have...

Join Medcast. It's free and you'll get instant access to essential healthcare news, research and more.

Already a member? Sign-in