lcp
We have detected you are using Internet Explorer. To provide the best and most secure experience, please use a modern browser as we do not support Internet Explorer.

Are we smarter than machines?

24 February 2015 - A/Prof Stephen Barnett

So, the Theory of Everything won an Oscar yesterday. As a result, I had a great discussion with Dr Malcolm Ireland today (Director of Training at Wentwest). We were discussing Stephen Hawking's recent comment that artificial intelligence will be 'the end of mankind'. 

Malcolm made two great points:

1. Expert systems have historically worked deductively... start with a large amount of information, then try to reduce the number of possibilities through iterative questioning until you arrive at the likely answer. And yet expert humans don't do that. We don't really know how they do it... some call it pattern recognition, or intuition... but a great clinician works in reverse. "A 67 year old man presents with cough, haemoptysis..." and they are already deducing that it may be TB, Ca Lung, acute pneumonia. They then work backwords, hypothesis testing against the likely outcomes, rather than starting with an exhaustive list and testing each one. Maybe that is what it is to master an art. It may be a while before machines are there (but they are getting smarter every day!!)

2. Malcolm also thought that, whilst machines rely on large data stores, so much of that data has been created by humans, is incomplete, is stored in inaccessible places, is not interoperable and is, essentially, human and messy. As a result, machines will have trouble for quite some time becoming highly accurate in some of the 'greyer' areas of human knowledge. In effect, our own human messiness and incompetence may save us yet!!

What do you think? Are the machines coming?...

A/Prof Stephen Barnett
A/Prof Stephen Barnett

Stephen is a GP Supervisor, Medical Educator, GP academic and Medical Director of Medcast. He has completed a PhD on Virtual Communities of Practice in GP Training.

Related Tags
Get Medcast Plus

Become a member and get unlimited access to 100s of hours of premium education.

Learn more
Related News
Critical care nutrition: enteral vs parenteral recommendations for the ICU patient

Susan Helmrich

Nutrition plays a vital role in the recovery of critically ill patients. Evidence-based recommendations for patients in the ICU focus on the timing, energy requirement and protein targets as well as the role of micronutrients. The route of administration is not always straightforward and best guided by the patient's clinical needs, indications and contraindications.

5 mins READ
Atrial fibrillation diagnosis and assessment - clinical fact sheet & MCQ

Medcast Medical Education Team

Brand icon

Atrial fibrillation (AF) is common and significantly impacts mortality, contributing to as many as 1 in 10 deaths in Australia. This FastTrack is the first of two, focusing on the diagnosis and management of AF, from the recommendations on opportunistic screening to identifying comorbidities and precipitating factors. Complete the quiz to earn 30mins EA and 30mins RP CPD.

15 mins READ
Supporting veterans’ mental health

Dr Catherine Eltringham

Brand icon

As veterans transition from military service, they often face significant mental health challenges, including post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, anxiety, and adjustment difficulties. Managing these complex conditions requires a holistic, long-term approach, and general practitioners (GPs) are in a unique position to support veterans not only through referrals to mental health specialists but also through evidence-based lifestyle interventions that promote resilience and recovery.

30 mins READ